Freud/Lynch:
Behind the Curtain

Review

By Oliver Cutler

Originally published in Cinematheme, 2022

Psychoanalysis — film

What exists ‘behind’ (or, perhaps more accurately, beneath, through or within) the curtain of the Lynchian oeuvre? If spectators are to believe the filmmaker’s own protestations, it is most certainly not anything belonging to the realm of psychoanalysis. Nevertheless, psychoanalytic interpretative frameworks are among the most commonly used to analyse the work of David Lynch. So much so, in fact, that Freudo-Lacanian pronouncements are ubiquitous to the point of sometimes remaining unnamed when they are employed. Lynch’s work, so the avowedly or implicitly psychoanalytic readings would suggest, is characterised by: dreams and wish fulfilment, perversion, (the separated realms of) desire and fantasy, the divided subject etc....the list goes on. For an (academic) reader acquainted with these interpretations, what new insights could (yet another) psychoanalytic treatment of Lynch’s work provide?

As it happens, quite a lot. From the ten essays in this collection (along with a transcript of a panel discussion which included three of the book’s contributors), the reader is presented with an assortment of interpretative treatments, ranging from the ambitious and theoretical, to the recognisably ‘conventional’ (if that is not too much of a contradiction in terms given Lynch’s idiosyncratic subject matter). Indeed, even for those authors whose essays adopt the latter approach, it is not so much that their judgments are trite, more that offering an original take on the Lynchian-narrative-as-dream method of analysis is challenging. Moreover, when an entire hypothesis is predicated on this premise, the argument can soon unravel if the reader exhibits their own negative reaction/resistance to this treatment.

This represents the main problem of the book. Olga Cox Cameron’s Dream logic in Mulholland Drive, while being theoretically coherent and considered, presents a totalizing, and perhaps slightly reductive, understanding of Lynch’s work, which may leave some readers a little irked. Cameron’s presentation of the diegesis as a dream, rather than a correlate of a dream – which can, just as effectively – offer insights into dreams, is problematic, in spite of a compelling assessment of how the former could be so. Structured this way, the essay is more useful in explicating the psychoanalytic phenomena than unravelling the layers of Lynchian narrative. Several of the essays state that the films exemplify particular psychoanalytic phenomena; the most successful are those that are able to adopt this approach without being reductive. Carol Owens, a practising psychoanalyst, has arguably the most astute method of manoeuvring around the issue of Lynch’s personal resistance to psychoanalytic readings being applied to his work. For Lynch need not ‘be a Freudian in order for the cultural moment that is “the Lynchian” to be so,’ (p.10).

There are few writers on Lynch more significant than Chris Rodley (Lynch on Lynch, 2005) and Todd McGowan (The Impossible David Lynch, 2007a; The Real Gaze, 2007b), so it seems appropriate that their contrasting essays on Lynch’s dreamlike creative process and ‘the end of fantasy’ should ‘bookend’ the collection. Rodley, a writer who has observed Lynch up close and knows him personally, presents a lucid hypothesis as to the disjuncture between Lynch’s dreamlike imagery and dialogue and the director’s own reticence when discussing his work. This, Rodley suggests, is owing to the director being the ‘dreamer’ of his own films, whose dream logic is then transposed into the manifest content of these artworks. Rodley suggests that Lynch need not trade in certitude, even in the context of a revival of ‘intentionality’, whereby directors laxly open the curtains onto their own work. Naming Lynch’s unwillingness in this regard a ‘defence mechanism’ is one of only a few theoretical nods in an accessible piece.

No stranger to writing about Lynch, Todd McGowan returns to familiar territory in Waiting for Agent Cooper: the ends of fantasy in Twin Peaks: The Return. McGowan’s (2007b) theory regarding the filmic-televisual representation of the realms of desire and fantasy – and where the ‘cuts’ between the two intervene – continues to provide a robust framework for understanding the ‘bizarre normality’ of Lynch. Like the contributions from Wild and Martin, McGowan gives prominence to setting in his piece. For McGowan, the (almost) complete abandonment of the titular town from series three of Twin Peaks marks a changed relationship with fantasy. Lynch’s move here, McGowan argues, is to situate the spectator away from the comfort and abundance of fantasmatic representations (which show how desire might be realised). In lieu of fantasy’s warmth, the spectator is offered the needling experience of continually delayed satisfaction in the realm of desire. McGowan’s essay is certainly a standout of the book. His contentions that Lynch emphasises how fantasy’s pursuance leads to a cul-de-sac and that Cooper’s (paternalistic) efforts to remove trauma and negativity only leads to a repetition of them are theoretically sound and elegantly executed.

Stefan Marianski’s Möbian adventures on the lost highway represents another standout essay in the collection. Something of an outlier in terms of its theoretical complexity, Marianski’s argument is a judicious appraisal of Lynch, which adopts McGowan’s (2007b) theory of the Lynchian representation of desire and fantasy. Marianski’s skilful intervention comprises an application of later Lacan to Lost Highway, in order to move analysis of the film beyond ‘psychogenic fugue’ and towards an understanding of the failure of symbolisation in the context of the fissure inherent in the sexual non-relationship. Marianski’s application of the Lacanian theory of the ‘minus-one’, in the context of the incompleteness of subjectivity, to the highly disturbing exchanges between ‘Fred’ and the ‘Mystery Man’ in Lost Highway is an especially precise insight. Moreover, the advancement of the McGowian understanding of filmic fantasy through these structural considerations is a highly satisfying development in Lacanian readings of Lynch. The theoretical complexity means that this is probably best suited to only the moderately-initiated Lacanian, however.

By completing a comparative analysis in his essay, Jamie Ruers presents a sophisticated synthesis of some famed examples of hysteria from psychoanalysis’ dawn, alongside contemporary manifestations of hysteria in Lynch. However, he does more than just tease out the parallels between Dora and Audrey Horne or ‘The Girl’ from The Alphabet and Charcot’s Augustine. Borrowing the Žižekian reading of Dorothy Vallens from Blue Velvet as too passive (and, therefore, her suffering being necessary so that she can be shaken out of her inertia), Ruers offers a considered argument of how Lynch hystericizes his audience too. Lynch, in Ruers’ contention, exploits the conventional representations of ‘Woman’ to subvert spectator assumptions. Moreover, as quintessential examples of subjects positioning themselves at the site of the Other’s desire, Lynch’s female characters do not seem to have a firm grip on their own desire. Ruers’ key insight, though, comes via the assertion that the ambiguity of Lynchian women allows the spectator to project their (ambivalent) desires on to them.

In both Mary Wild’s Lost angels in Los Angeles: Lynchian psychogenic fugues and Richard Martin’s David Lynch sprawls, Lynch’s manipulation of the spatiotemporal is explored. Martin emphasises how the familiar evocation of Twin Peaks from the original series has been abandoned in the recent series. Suggesting that The Return is evocative of the concepts of ‘junk-space’ (Koolhaas) and ‘junk-time’ (Steyerl), Martin explores how Lynch represents spaces which emphasise the malaise of the contemporary world. The Return has none of the warmth of the first two series; instead, the world is now characterised by the emptiness of spaces; of discontinuous time; and of cause and effect as interrupted. The world represented, in Martin’s contention, is reflective of the cultural move towards ‘sprawl’, with all its connotations of lethargy and distractedness. Nevertheless, The Return requires our full attention. Lynch’s freedom in extending the parameters of time and space mirrors the intertextuality of Lynch’s work – the developing sense of free association across his output. But it is also an examination of control/authority over letting go – both for the filmmaker and his audience.

Space is similarly explored by Wild, who reveals the (psychoanalytic) origin of Lost Highway (1997) in a lucid and engagingly written essay. Like Rodley, Wild is not preoccupied with complex theoretical matters, and this does not detract in the slightest from her argument. Highlighting Lynch’s affection for Tinseltown, Wild stresses how the dichotomous ‘psychic geography’ explored through Lynch’s triad of LA-based films bespeaks an obsession with memory and forgetting; glitz and grime; and spectators’ identification with illusion. Foremost in her argument, however, is an insistence on the complementarity between the destabilising nature of scotomization and psychogenic fugue and the experience of spectatorship, which is itself a type of forgetting.

Adopting an approach with echoes of Rodley, Allister Mactaggart’s “It is an illusion”: the artful life of David Lynch focuses not just on content but on the process that makes Lynch’s work so unique. For readers not acquainted with Lynch’s wider artistic output, Mactaggart’s examination of the influence of Transcendental Meditation and painterly practices on Lynch’s film and television work will prove enlightening. Analysing Lynch’s work without cognisance of these dimensions to his thought risks rather missing the point, Mactaggart argues. Taking his lead from Freud, Mactaggart asserts how – especially in the context of Lynch’s particular process as an artist – expecting the author of the work to fully comprehend the meaning of their own work is misguided. Notwithstanding, Mactaggart provides an apposite synthesising of the Lacanian development of sublimation and the (possibly unconscious) representation of the nuclear age in The Return. In company with McGowan’s assertion regarding the risk to subjectivity by attempting to erase trauma, this is undoubtedly the key political reflection in the collection. Reflecting on Lynch’s environmental awareness represents a noteworthy broadening of what can be considered as significant in his work.

The connection between Lynch and perversion is nothing new (see, for example, Johnson, 2004). Nevertheless, Andrea Sabbadini illuminates the discussion through an untangling of the various modes of perversion that the spectator observes in Lynch’s characters. As a psychoanalyst in professional practice, it is perhaps unsurprising that Sabbadini recognises perverse patterns as they emerge in filmic form. Previous studies of Lynch have not identified perversions with such clarity, so this is a valuable development. Echoing Baudry’s (1974) contention that the experience of spectatorship can activate regression, Sabbadini proposes an intriguing hypothesis as to the connection between partial objects (he gives the example of the severed ear in Blue Velvet) and castration anxiety. The essay would have been more persuasive had Sabbadini clearly identified a theory of audience identification, as opposed to leaving this implicit and equating the experience of the spectator with that of the protagonist, however.

By combining the highly theoretical with the more accessible, the political with the pop cultural (who knew there was a connection between the O.J Simpson trial and Lost Highway?) the editors have assembled a well-chosen selection of essays. Indeed, this collection raises several important questions, pertinent both to psychoanalysis and an appreciation of Lynch. What are the implications of trying to interrupt trauma? To what extent is Lynch’s oeuvre an attempt to confront the malevolence of the Other? At what point do hysteric representations begin to hystericize the spectator? Can the free association of psychoanalysis be reconciled with the free association of transcendental meditation? By exploring these questions, the reader can begin to peer behind the Lynchian curtain and will, most likely, see quite a bit more than they might have expected to. The collection feels fresh and unquestionably offers more than just a rehashing of the popular psychoanalytic readings of Lynch.

Reference list

  • Baudry, J. & Williams, A. (1974) ‘Ideological Effects of the Basic Cinematographic Apparatus’ in Film quarterly, 1974-12-01, Vol.28 (2), p.39-47
  • Johnson, J. (2004) Pervert in the Pulpit: Morality in the Works of David Lynch. McFarland, USA.
  • McGowan, T, (2007a) The Impossible David Lynch, Columbia University Press, USA.
  • McGowan, T. (2007b) The Real Gaze: Film Theory after Lacan, Ithaca: State University of New York Press, USA
  • Rodley, C. (2005) Lynch on Lynch, Faber & Faber, USA.

← Back to the archive